[ { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 553650.585813669, "total_return": 4.536505858136691, "cagr": 0.09509261065859964, "annualized_volatility": 0.10488335377252463, "max_drawdown": -0.21844238584577913, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-05", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 107, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 504, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-20", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2009-10-06", "id": "policy", "case": { "id": "policy", "rule": "policy" }, "ledger": { "costs": 1307.6139879717264, "traded_dollars": 2517334.0279290387, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 343.3461444316987, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 114436.90729278629, "IEF": 15089.378345667694, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 178919.32683759628, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 16260.746521458985, "XLI": 52202.94364742248, "XLK": 66783.04402284602, "XLU": 10922.506989426473 }, "max_self_financing_error": 4.773028194904327e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.07334888576588705, "2009": 0.13164767552322387, "2010": 0.18664124024631934, "2011": 0.0946503203895015, "2012": 0.10757908779985481, "2013": 0.069818820885442, "2014": 0.08956627674657125, "2015": -0.02743207492012778, "2016": 0.10865177614465904, "2017": 0.1728361371848548, "2018": -0.05107842151076403, "2019": 0.20775290559699378, "2020": 0.16134519867918162, "2021": 0.061490338943121836, "2022": -0.08709498121405679, "2023": 0.17199304044495634, "2024": 0.18834015286066208, "2025": 0.27456949037643374, "2026": 0.0873807767927608 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.510673013252337, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.592341841560406, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.05594084823675005, "rolling10_median": 0.08668810523967274, "rolling10_ge6_count": 105, "rolling10_ge8_count": 76 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 348136.67130819627, "total_return": 2.4813667130819628, "cagr": 0.06845442188940032, "annualized_volatility": 0.07550563075708266, "max_drawdown": -0.18560152782696593, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-20", "max_dd_trough": "2008-11-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2009-10-07", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 505, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 563, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-31", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-07-17", "id": "variable_BIL", "case": { "id": "variable_BIL", "rule": "variable_BIL" }, "ledger": { "costs": 665.3417535382872, "traded_dollars": 1034936.1125179504, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 14245.620332424249, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 85949.02530755902, "IEF": 13416.89022735819, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 135190.47719439009, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.026798367500305e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.07334888576588705, "2009": 0.13164767552322387, "2010": 0.138026806399705, "2011": 0.06887947308013498, "2012": 0.07311490062313442, "2013": -0.005359287806708135, "2014": 0.05388455071444698, "2015": -0.01674945026782848, "2016": 0.06201704206278058, "2017": 0.10184735443528714, "2018": -0.008392917935022837, "2019": 0.15790738376684121, "2020": 0.1479180782046836, "2021": 0.06367540201366406, "2022": -0.08186907037861135, "2023": 0.12989198719823958, "2024": 0.1503393826438102, "2025": 0.22254732851383707, "2026": 0.03098363732684284 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.30056137948123257, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.33496704480426726, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.038092699086864856, "rolling10_median": 0.06044913662120577, "rolling10_ge6_count": 54, "rolling10_ge8_count": 15 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 471557.11439634324, "total_return": 3.715571143963432, "cagr": 0.08580316888061712, "annualized_volatility": 0.10812812301763647, "max_drawdown": -0.2960531347827571, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-20", "max_dd_trough": "2008-11-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2010-03-17", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 666, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 665, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-20", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2010-03-16", "id": "variable_equal_pool", "case": { "id": "variable_equal_pool", "rule": "variable_equal_pool" }, "ledger": { "costs": 1243.3415742702641, "traded_dollars": 1397297.4169266568, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 2544.7042674913364, "DBC": 10070.401063540186, "GLD": 101742.03732149111, "IEF": 13536.741314364675, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 156540.10983956966, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 12142.679908456326, "XLE": 18360.610590951368, "XLI": 17430.607051580973, "XLK": 27368.60381854668, "XLU": 13063.96079461771 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.4924596548080444e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.1531884605823035, "2009": 0.1903261912203702, "2010": 0.1802462732659491, "2011": 0.08182949018972141, "2012": 0.09520039404629999, "2013": 0.027370257171164925, "2014": 0.06885914757814193, "2015": -0.034720187667399705, "2016": 0.10119102073148722, "2017": 0.12920350304866868, "2018": -0.02755679922616705, "2019": 0.21198980933092493, "2020": 0.15394051622749627, "2021": 0.13695905263493158, "2022": -0.08103934017776093, "2023": 0.14294977328140024, "2024": 0.16798579776321687, "2025": 0.2454070712487566, "2026": 0.07437654142551398 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.4790620621541364, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.514734023742509, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.05536781067504104, "rolling10_median": 0.07849175553305732, "rolling10_ge6_count": 105, "rolling10_ge8_count": 47 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 471954.5186700153, "total_return": 3.719545186700153, "cagr": 0.08585172073910363, "annualized_volatility": 0.10863000659724993, "max_drawdown": -0.27350389579378986, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-20", "max_dd_trough": "2009-03-09", "max_dd_recovery": "2010-04-09", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 689, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 688, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-20", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2010-04-08", "id": "variable_XLU", "case": { "id": "variable_XLU", "rule": "variable_XLU" }, "ledger": { "costs": 773.4201925213973, "traded_dollars": 1338655.0621118722, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 0.0, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 105492.83338313295, "IEF": 13491.472238871114, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 161769.73920072938, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 91973.89403979956 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.725290298461914e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.15084932961318076, "2009": 0.1626474865607832, "2010": 0.1535208099754921, "2011": 0.11799573393915286, "2012": 0.07644202518907095, "2013": 0.02769647523862684, "2014": 0.12399167030398028, "2015": -0.027318685461698133, "2016": 0.10323742214046794, "2017": 0.13228202909733544, "2018": -0.0017629635810099131, "2019": 0.22069773150124017, "2020": 0.15108005499538435, "2021": 0.10970222412442387, "2022": -0.0806928319832585, "2023": 0.09637955588156055, "2024": 0.19877177986551464, "2025": 0.25608980870424114, "2026": 0.03861932299694848 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.55032982898288, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5791466471436184, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.06246391173287158, "rolling10_median": 0.08663246644221811, "rolling10_ge6_count": 106, "rolling10_ge8_count": 73 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 547627.5768322651, "total_return": 4.476275768322651, "cagr": 0.0944569792693486, "annualized_volatility": 0.11618942653031418, "max_drawdown": -0.30275635487091324, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-20", "max_dd_trough": "2008-11-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2009-12-02", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 561, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 703, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-27", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-11-30", "id": "variable_SPY", "case": { "id": "variable_SPY", "rule": "variable_SPY" }, "ledger": { "costs": 673.0405577954186, "traded_dollars": 1317467.5726335708, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 0.0, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 115517.98112676908, "IEF": 13898.232420419416, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 318884.4038428651, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 6.984919309616089e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.17367701064717622, "2009": 0.20011512056424285, "2010": 0.18005465835737566, "2011": 0.07509000489273121, "2012": 0.11415661620849815, "2013": 0.06777451304639803, "2014": 0.08799484384160006, "2015": -0.012343178361352236, "2016": 0.09285315636534919, "2017": 0.15530520634468137, "2018": -0.022971208573676738, "2019": 0.2336922665665766, "2020": 0.19793853379102955, "2021": 0.13367440365236982, "2022": -0.12957541849563536, "2023": 0.1821304032579263, "2024": 0.20096621053274966, "2025": 0.26059850054040323, "2026": 0.05756529076653116 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5504302337251233, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5883634645632808, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.06625368088174155, "rolling10_median": 0.09484386552942736, "rolling10_ge6_count": 106, "rolling10_ge8_count": 88 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 409484.7199343029, "total_return": 3.094847199343029, "cagr": 0.07769902500177572, "annualized_volatility": 0.10484132611786252, "max_drawdown": -0.2828762933521688, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-21", "max_dd_trough": "2008-11-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2010-04-09", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 688, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 724, "longest_underwater_start": "2022-03-08", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2024-03-01", "id": "momentum_original_pool", "case": { "id": "momentum_original_pool", "rule": "momentum_original_pool" }, "ledger": { "costs": 3229.582599387327, "traded_dollars": 6812515.948233603, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 1401.3814076035217, "DBC": 23724.702726449876, "GLD": 92418.98608064026, "IEF": 13685.198100160826, "IGF": 16672.869968319977, "SPY": 146132.6573846489, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 851.3336714034791, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 17827.17319445967 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.725290298461914e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.12884232297975218, "2009": 0.17052767735134178, "2010": 0.21398404876136268, "2011": 0.06527037240754407, "2012": 0.0821977685781683, "2013": 0.029716310164120685, "2014": 0.10297641233022437, "2015": -0.0068165198519780645, "2016": 0.050803539064834036, "2017": 0.0950706492515141, "2018": -0.06800426144727945, "2019": 0.21517028348414802, "2020": 0.07746484364093775, "2021": 0.14705459143620425, "2022": -0.04017622333466264, "2023": 0.09377507713802258, "2024": 0.12462342118685443, "2025": 0.24629119734338456, "2026": 0.07329318238847704 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.4558500093039677, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5775244791361244, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.05012338860455334, "rolling10_median": 0.06601255043312726, "rolling10_ge6_count": 83, "rolling10_ge8_count": 22 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 517066.24411527364, "total_return": 4.170662441152737, "cagr": 0.0911260638832434, "annualized_volatility": 0.11536409957520022, "max_drawdown": -0.2828775765280792, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-21", "max_dd_trough": "2008-11-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2010-04-14", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 693, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 692, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-21", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2010-04-13", "id": "momentum_same_pool", "case": { "id": "momentum_same_pool", "rule": "momentum_same_pool" }, "ledger": { "costs": 3400.971028866625, "traded_dollars": 7739793.789349397, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 49.479154586927955, "DBC": -6069.444317382135, "GLD": 114902.73339781964, "IEF": 12999.924795767007, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 165419.0654064169, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 17107.949989509096, "XLE": 41991.179722075925, "XLI": -6416.944594672993, "XLK": 61359.35395923129, "XLU": 19123.917630785236 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.3760443329811096e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.14776372623984313, "2009": 0.16783368601679838, "2010": 0.20267857936643274, "2011": 0.04274845780058345, "2012": 0.04627326339247628, "2013": 0.05788177121115479, "2014": 0.08313345880917167, "2015": -0.024863362877715844, "2016": 0.0520642118775394, "2017": 0.14582700873111154, "2018": -0.014989937583246848, "2019": 0.21647157394952599, "2020": 0.2584587371124001, "2021": 0.14437985701152822, "2022": 0.04853466303204379, "2023": 0.1287653118959775, "2024": 0.12943811834122432, "2025": 0.24396526490765957, "2026": 0.024415339882907894 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5213889597789299, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5847083295782516, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.053680077769480805, "rolling10_median": 0.09142139304878094, "rolling10_ge6_count": 100, "rolling10_ge8_count": 82 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 324271.952646944, "total_return": 2.2427195264694397, "cagr": 0.06443463531022209, "annualized_volatility": 0.07457767111170965, "max_drawdown": -0.1750893535784368, "max_dd_peak": "2021-12-27", "max_dd_trough": "2022-10-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2024-03-06", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 800, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 799, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-27", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2024-03-05", "id": "permanent_monthly", "case": { "id": "permanent_monthly", "rule": "permanent_monthly" }, "ledger": { "costs": 700.922311681596, "traded_dollars": 1143672.4481687641, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 13895.526661590322, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 84656.34016376402, "IEF": 0.0, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 114366.20291102873, "TLT": 12054.805222239294, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.2014213502407074e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.014119163687748237, "2009": 0.06771344079391306, "2010": 0.13596859489691893, "2011": 0.1205275186972794, "2012": 0.06617303974196664, "2013": -0.04064160713457321, "2014": 0.09419783903281709, "2015": -0.022925682072513776, "2016": 0.057852494354617034, "2017": 0.1097374289769597, "2018": -0.011715022459667379, "2019": 0.16381647914983422, "2020": 0.16546216371878564, "2021": 0.046027303148157506, "2022": -0.12590246547193107, "2023": 0.11757361616476159, "2024": 0.11685468951565192, "2025": 0.2073786498570509, "2026": 0.020657262331662096 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.25066184603123054, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.2844114043602903, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.03339069948083906, "rolling10_median": 0.06140488923725207, "rolling10_ge6_count": 58, "rolling10_ge8_count": 3 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 553997.1184690708, "total_return": 4.539971184690708, "cagr": 0.09512898208505582, "annualized_volatility": 0.10488378915150061, "max_drawdown": -0.21844144069132687, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-05", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 107, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 504, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-20", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2009-10-06", "id": "policy_5bps", "case": { "id": "policy_5bps", "rule": "policy", "cost": 5.0 }, "ledger": { "costs": 1259.4339680262635, "traded_dollars": 2518867.9360525273, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 343.2500554802776, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 114511.25423234358, "IEF": 15096.090410903895, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 179043.26584550532, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 16269.653472542817, "XLI": 52235.45863633386, "XLK": 66828.26933757277, "XLU": 10929.310446410575 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.958120942115784e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.07337588030529263, "2009": 0.1317689202305823, "2010": 0.1868082271135787, "2011": 0.09477192701409964, "2012": 0.10769522535626441, "2013": 0.06990365084706118, "2014": 0.08965982564082497, "2015": -0.027377558663770674, "2016": 0.10871249673051553, "2017": 0.17292243838031363, "2018": -0.051053781375326346, "2019": 0.20779158453745517, "2020": 0.16131369407368168, "2021": 0.061455876309695734, "2022": -0.08713456026652644, "2023": 0.17198421863646218, "2024": 0.18831291450789123, "2025": 0.2745298392410864, "2026": 0.08732426542070115 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5106730132523372, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.592341841560406, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.05597560327029427, "rolling10_median": 0.0867181779677525, "rolling10_ge6_count": 105, "rolling10_ge8_count": 76 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 544743.9562875011, "total_return": 4.447439562875012, "cagr": 0.09415031277134589, "annualized_volatility": 0.10487843600700396, "max_drawdown": -0.21848501088806893, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-05", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 107, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 525, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-31", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-06-09", "id": "policy_20bps", "case": { "id": "policy_20bps", "rule": "policy", "cost": 20.0 }, "ledger": { "costs": 4983.458594636765, "traded_dollars": 2491729.2973183827, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 343.5208433300445, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 113033.1706923065, "IEF": 15008.058849164516, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 176886.51681565447, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 15943.083674259862, "XLI": 51661.16567544617, "XLK": 66067.27056051079, "XLU": 10784.627771461253 }, "max_self_financing_error": 4.307366907596588e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.07543555454124695, "2009": 0.1309770276029596, "2010": 0.18529263045960676, "2011": 0.09370850491739224, "2012": 0.10683643637852569, "2013": 0.06934081717717211, "2014": 0.08927515537456432, "2015": -0.028194659316587822, "2016": 0.10780307717271587, "2017": 0.17260434450440343, "2018": -0.051799817161712114, "2019": 0.20715043433304148, "2020": 0.15989979089906314, "2021": 0.060293524326861414, "2022": -0.0882721734023747, "2023": 0.17110405606811652, "2024": 0.18741121766206637, "2025": 0.27356850381970954, "2026": 0.08630449362319181 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.510673013252337, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.592341841560406, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.055173138215249606, "rolling10_median": 0.08586128935081472, "rolling10_ge6_count": 105, "rolling10_ge8_count": 74 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 562941.7388730599, "total_return": 4.629417388730599, "cagr": 0.09606041469582349, "annualized_volatility": 0.10474995356524042, "max_drawdown": -0.21844234005844032, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-05", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 107, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 504, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-20", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2009-10-06", "id": "policy_delay_Feb", "case": { "id": "policy_delay_Feb", "rule": "policy", "delay": true }, "ledger": { "costs": 1324.928635971337, "traded_dollars": 2569347.43108088, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 347.6722798494795, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 117129.6092203631, "IEF": 15246.51936993044, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 181851.57328379617, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 11075.127765735457, "XLI": 54505.68832978807, "XLK": 69851.62300849841, "XLU": 14258.854251064427 }, "max_self_financing_error": 5.704350769519806e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.07334888576588705, "2009": 0.13164767552322387, "2010": 0.20308672989869025, "2011": 0.0974119274285008, "2012": 0.09796687615379018, "2013": 0.06981989406367695, "2014": 0.0895672472412985, "2015": -0.032937337380858134, "2016": 0.12009004094226272, "2017": 0.17283758240496971, "2018": -0.047756908685188115, "2019": 0.20775455969330392, "2020": 0.15300514420220024, "2021": 0.07171092064038898, "2022": -0.07975963580959544, "2023": 0.16002502332167778, "2024": 0.19575019882623557, "2025": 0.28156256378352795, "2026": 0.0756863265542016 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5096364416499864, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.592341841560406, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.05789154661790752, "rolling10_median": 0.08742871659634277, "rolling10_ge6_count": 105, "rolling10_ge8_count": 78 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 565669.9037948756, "total_return": 4.656699037948756, "cagr": 0.09634171934054292, "annualized_volatility": 0.11012609123915484, "max_drawdown": -0.2537739426022325, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-20", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-18", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-08", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 109, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 504, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-20", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2009-10-06", "id": "policy_primary_only", "case": { "id": "policy_primary_only", "rule": "policy", "primary": true }, "ledger": { "costs": 1475.2797186369176, "traded_dollars": 3092765.138963318, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 348.34153790857744, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 112399.56230799622, "IEF": 15822.899223910716, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 176483.15718561097, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 24276.519823004688, "XLI": 72531.06991790672, "XLK": 65283.63351716994, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 4.773028194904327e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.07334888576588705, "2009": 0.13164767552322387, "2010": 0.20695856277962443, "2011": 0.06977672510945232, "2012": 0.11477541629779786, "2013": 0.08689935852819297, "2014": 0.08089481898459194, "2015": -0.02626066377974201, "2016": 0.11320011434584276, "2017": 0.16116144544997524, "2018": -0.05906950324520799, "2019": 0.2330562023463043, "2020": 0.07131115308812941, "2021": 0.06386981635345834, "2022": -0.095965033474811, "2023": 0.2515776090005595, "2024": 0.17763387758185822, "2025": 0.28027291925521314, "2026": 0.12352042300715027 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5107277508150116, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.6043872157128194, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.045643109279657645, "rolling10_median": 0.08317580141578529, "rolling10_ge6_count": 100, "rolling10_ge8_count": 62 }, { "start": "2008-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 18.839538115087922, "final_value": 491080.5929643053, "total_return": 3.910805929643053, "cagr": 0.0881437969741814, "annualized_volatility": 0.11219616739227543, "max_drawdown": -0.3062401072202443, "max_dd_peak": "2008-05-19", "max_dd_trough": "2008-11-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2010-09-20", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 854, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 851, "longest_underwater_start": "2008-05-19", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2010-09-17", "id": "policy_2007_candidate", "case": { "id": "policy_2007_candidate", "rule": "policy", "use_2007_candidate": true }, "ledger": { "costs": 1237.8103102505897, "traded_dollars": 2295301.8607937912, "rebalance_events": 227, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": -29.789645137965287, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 101466.76855843149, "IEF": 13465.368652343328, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 157784.68600486525, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 14422.661204083275, "XLI": 46306.34540484914, "XLK": 49213.85598527837, "XLU": 9688.507109838954 }, "max_self_financing_error": 4.0745362639427185e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2008": -0.1851015414593462, "2009": 0.14164287784257912, "2010": 0.1866144869200821, "2011": 0.0946284209713315, "2012": 0.10756027144900182, "2013": 0.06980070545961348, "2014": 0.08954989434143346, "2015": -0.02744598060634107, "2016": 0.10863703700775962, "2017": 0.1728209092519839, "2018": -0.05108962780698889, "2019": 0.20773934240949377, "2020": 0.1613343288294351, "2021": 0.06148294545904198, "2022": -0.08710291490687327, "2023": 0.1719832283714704, "2024": 0.18833194895447347, "2025": 0.27456204432016107, "2026": 0.08737610418953268 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5239055110751679, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5923418415604061, "rolling10_count": 106, "rolling10_min": 0.05592793781095384, "rolling10_median": 0.08624017751966129, "rolling10_ge6_count": 105, "rolling10_ge8_count": 68 }, { "start": "2010-01-04", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 16.832652278965345, "final_value": 522054.61466389045, "total_return": 4.220546146638904, "cagr": 0.1031595157589218, "annualized_volatility": 0.1033636893960178, "max_drawdown": -0.21844271521915182, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-05", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 107, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 434, "longest_underwater_start": "2018-01-26", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2019-04-05", "id": "policy_start_2010", "case": { "id": "policy_start_2010", "rule": "policy", "start": "2010-01-04" }, "ledger": { "costs": 1169.2020384845343, "traded_dollars": 2241363.351805747, "rebalance_events": 203, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": -77.66579543077881, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 100921.66003958552, "IEF": 12609.579694896065, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 171939.45928874405, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 15332.568119845815, "XLI": 49225.33729433264, "XLK": 62973.50432500905, "XLU": 10299.373735388963 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.6088749766349792e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2010": 0.17345070866115075, "2011": 0.0946399169528156, "2012": 0.10757014908479734, "2013": 0.06981021522185005, "2014": 0.08955849441699182, "2015": -0.027438680652194347, "2016": 0.10864477454423738, "2017": 0.17282890343990753, "2018": -0.05108374481609035, "2019": 0.20774646274208686, "2020": 0.1613400352578327, "2021": 0.0614868268903479, "2022": -0.08709874986300281, "2023": 0.17198837955215995, "2024": 0.18833623567907787, "2025": 0.27456595340719825, "2026": 0.08737858880508864 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5360456365743045, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.592341841560406, "rolling10_count": 82, "rolling10_min": 0.05593471535246408, "rolling10_median": 0.08543184950894733, "rolling10_ge6_count": 81, "rolling10_ge8_count": 52 }, { "start": "2010-01-04", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 16.832652278965345, "final_value": 460995.31085428316, "total_return": 3.6099531085428316, "cagr": 0.09503779890880226, "annualized_volatility": 0.09559969771716813, "max_drawdown": -0.19076958265660993, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-20", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-08", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 109, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 475, "longest_underwater_start": "2022-03-30", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-07-18", "id": "variable_equal_pool_start_2010", "case": { "id": "variable_equal_pool_start_2010", "rule": "variable_equal_pool", "start": "2010-01-04" }, "ledger": { "costs": 1117.7523164439872, "traded_dollars": 1267794.715955849, "rebalance_events": 203, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 2428.5514608628923, "DBC": 10177.77237559037, "GLD": 92935.31618168793, "IEF": 11646.10155444736, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 157042.46566730906, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 11521.916308454769, "XLE": 18523.910297368482, "XLI": 17542.86956666718, "XLK": 26904.87823309972, "XLU": 13389.281525236278 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.14321368932724e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2010": 0.16310337752728743, "2011": 0.08182208226449972, "2012": 0.09519357779290627, "2013": 0.027363925567047698, "2014": 0.06885314375337925, "2015": -0.034725355621693876, "2016": 0.10118500233968408, "2017": 0.1291980229354861, "2018": -0.027561349793139178, "2019": 0.21198456445553626, "2020": 0.1539357681452893, "2021": 0.13695520897519664, "2022": -0.0810425095555034, "2023": 0.14294601210102797, "2024": 0.16798249376109675, "2025": 0.24540421872491325, "2026": 0.07437456433676237 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.4794356718526949, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5147340237425091, "rolling10_count": 82, "rolling10_min": 0.05536275308729599, "rolling10_median": 0.07832784586607133, "rolling10_ge6_count": 81, "rolling10_ge8_count": 34 }, { "start": "2010-01-04", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 16.832652278965345, "final_value": 511630.97618683346, "total_return": 4.116309761868335, "cagr": 0.10183852067263732, "annualized_volatility": 0.11061703516847989, "max_drawdown": -0.18766625077784882, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-05-29", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 100, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 463, "longest_underwater_start": "2015-01-22", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2016-04-29", "id": "momentum_same_pool_start_2010", "case": { "id": "momentum_same_pool_start_2010", "rule": "momentum_same_pool", "start": "2010-01-04" }, "ledger": { "costs": 3240.799654887144, "traded_dollars": 7432239.103535475, "rebalance_events": 203, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 0.0, "DBC": -2095.4106398973595, "GLD": 107310.75036066395, "IEF": 11229.189532736755, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 167631.15425781213, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 16928.308573805873, "XLE": 44084.847341058616, "XLI": -6349.417486348882, "XLK": 57209.38734239878, "XLU": 18922.966559487195 }, "max_self_financing_error": 3.4924596548080444e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2010": 0.1844233309401795, "2011": 0.04274715166615639, "2012": 0.04627197120347226, "2013": 0.05788044435416495, "2014": 0.08313228054333277, "2015": -0.024864427320357985, "2016": 0.05206313592669587, "2017": 0.14582583768632285, "2018": -0.01499089428559841, "2019": 0.21647058066994118, "2020": 0.2584577791381535, "2021": 0.1443791832426755, "2022": 0.048534115048814774, "2023": 0.12876472848753573, "2024": 0.12943764166996052, "2025": 0.24396483163031912, "2026": 0.024415076018770687 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.543024110148254, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5847083295782515, "rolling10_count": 82, "rolling10_min": 0.0670856799368662, "rolling10_median": 0.09618486016307126, "rolling10_ge6_count": 82, "rolling10_ge8_count": 73 }, { "start": "2010-01-04", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 16.832652278965345, "final_value": 328194.88681900623, "total_return": 2.2819488681900624, "cagr": 0.07315520481533189, "annualized_volatility": 0.068946278658471, "max_drawdown": -0.1309399995838515, "max_dd_peak": "2021-12-31", "max_dd_trough": "2022-10-14", "max_dd_recovery": "2023-07-18", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 564, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 563, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-31", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-07-17", "id": "variable_BIL_start_2010", "case": { "id": "variable_BIL_start_2010", "rule": "variable_BIL", "start": "2010-01-04" }, "ledger": { "costs": 582.7019346649721, "traded_dollars": 893337.284168848, "rebalance_events": 203, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 13028.424822638843, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 74042.73890723726, "IEF": 11030.023007729396, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 130676.40201606318, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 2.5029294192790985e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2010": 0.1251252556886271, "2011": 0.06887107720038932, "2012": 0.07310725995695755, "2013": -0.005366707692855521, "2014": 0.053877419304072305, "2015": -0.01675627016548409, "2016": 0.062010105728732556, "2017": 0.10184039099149134, "2018": -0.008399033786967158, "2019": 0.1579008247381224, "2020": 0.14791223541527487, "2021": 0.06367050232535343, "2022": -0.08187327388759702, "2023": 0.12988706374169778, "2024": 0.1503348429754019, "2025": 0.22254319617423768, "2026": 0.030980866113846428 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.30088528347968546, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.33235615938416313, "rolling10_count": 82, "rolling10_min": 0.038086416844335336, "rolling10_median": 0.06034723626950711, "rolling10_ge6_count": 41, "rolling10_ge8_count": 15 }, { "start": "2010-01-04", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 16.832652278965345, "final_value": 304997.37734, "total_return": 2.0499737734, "cagr": 0.0684918888301338, "annualized_volatility": 0.07032855105980941, "max_drawdown": -0.17509244720872985, "max_dd_peak": "2021-12-27", "max_dd_trough": "2022-10-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2024-03-06", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 800, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 799, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-27", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2024-03-05", "id": "permanent_monthly_start_2010", "case": { "id": "permanent_monthly_start_2010", "rule": "permanent_monthly", "start": "2010-01-04" }, "ledger": { "costs": 614.5964405286593, "traded_dollars": 989966.1294100559, "rebalance_events": 203, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 12668.969467198838, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 72375.39547346211, "IEF": 0.0, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 110117.88168378158, "TLT": 10449.727156083702, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 2.444721758365631e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2010": 0.12479040071341396, "2011": 0.12051830122881535, "2012": 0.06616550610127114, "2013": -0.040648867141081624, "2014": 0.09419031329079441, "2015": -0.022932438957962265, "2016": 0.05784551373313396, "2017": 0.10973039472221391, "2018": -0.011721165060960437, "2019": 0.1638097713921962, "2020": 0.16545652199294536, "2021": 0.04602279433152545, "2022": -0.12590648136841553, "2023": 0.1175682583232418, "2024": 0.1168501577447354, "2025": 0.20737427586711998, "2026": 0.02065421440977877 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.2509340178890047, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.28441140436029033, "rolling10_count": 82, "rolling10_min": 0.03338445776016319, "rolling10_median": 0.060955560540303155, "rolling10_ge6_count": 44, "rolling10_ge8_count": 3 }, { "start": "2020-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 6.839291703457292, "final_value": 215089.4304088585, "total_return": 1.150894304088585, "cagr": 0.1184937329540674, "annualized_volatility": 0.12464264327372508, "max_drawdown": -0.21845094705007195, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-05", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 107, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 434, "longest_underwater_start": "2022-03-30", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-06-07", "id": "policy_start_2020", "case": { "id": "policy_start_2020", "rule": "policy", "start": "2020-01-02" }, "ledger": { "costs": 377.9669477952497, "traded_dollars": 677462.3531169585, "rebalance_events": 83, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": -32.01279046822304, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 35897.269646759305, "IEF": -299.9339508510383, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 43756.14751230032, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 6951.542455849758, "XLI": 8941.18333359595, "XLK": 16581.366584114716, "XLU": 3671.8345653524148 }, "max_self_financing_error": 5.238689482212067e-10 }, "annual_returns": { "2020": 0.15050211667311264, "2021": 0.06139904324481216, "2022": -0.08719295522387649, "2023": 0.1718718581616454, "2024": 0.1882388201790004, "2025": 0.27447705230801045, "2026": 0.08732178759984244 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5142561993601416, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.592341841560406, "rolling10_count": 0, "rolling10_min": null, "rolling10_median": null, "rolling10_ge6_count": 0, "rolling10_ge8_count": 0 }, { "start": "2020-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 6.839291703457292, "final_value": 213670.5799604336, "total_return": 1.1367057996043357, "cagr": 0.11741188496957644, "annualized_volatility": 0.11484453662527813, "max_drawdown": -0.19078482990652923, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-20", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-06-08", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 109, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 475, "longest_underwater_start": "2022-03-30", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-07-18", "id": "variable_equal_pool_start_2020", "case": { "id": "variable_equal_pool_start_2020", "rule": "variable_equal_pool", "start": "2020-01-02" }, "ledger": { "costs": 423.3657881962758, "traded_dollars": 429865.29203151364, "rebalance_events": 83, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 993.9089668750003, "DBC": 5504.280889686173, "GLD": 37186.52208328501, "IEF": -403.0278572863408, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 44617.890291543925, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 2486.140736138922, "XLE": 7569.229610375893, "XLI": 4735.41255688753, "XLK": 8090.668101940919, "XLU": 3312.9203691819935 }, "max_self_financing_error": 8.440110832452774e-10 }, "annual_returns": { "2020": 0.14591171101023526, "2021": 0.13676108817822197, "2022": -0.08120287950618821, "2023": 0.14275935323450129, "2024": 0.16781624792835537, "2025": 0.24526278774496668, "2026": 0.07427244993272852 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.47929710609945664, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5147340237425089, "rolling10_count": 0, "rolling10_min": null, "rolling10_median": null, "rolling10_ge6_count": 0, "rolling10_ge8_count": 0 }, { "start": "2020-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 6.839291703457292, "final_value": 242642.66997351518, "total_return": 1.4264266997351518, "cagr": 0.1383808453529034, "annualized_volatility": 0.13434967354417085, "max_drawdown": -0.18767219193643836, "max_dd_peak": "2020-02-19", "max_dd_trough": "2020-03-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2020-05-29", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 100, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 293, "longest_underwater_start": "2022-03-25", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-01-12", "id": "momentum_same_pool_start_2020", "case": { "id": "momentum_same_pool_start_2020", "rule": "momentum_same_pool", "start": "2020-01-02" }, "ledger": { "costs": 1014.9095726330626, "traded_dollars": 2363281.54312373, "rebalance_events": 83, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 0.0, "DBC": 1177.7265525411372, "GLD": 44661.06241170945, "IEF": -530.0333657928833, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 51874.042329149524, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 23455.925147931488, "XLI": -7027.251667628392, "XLK": 26959.313774237635, "XLU": 3086.79436399923 }, "max_self_financing_error": 1.0477378964424133e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2020": 0.24505507508363555, "2021": 0.14430753691813614, "2022": 0.048472521101635024, "2023": 0.12870321188263634, "2024": 0.12938737703706837, "2025": 0.24391914080189037, "2026": 0.024386770890983733 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.5350919496395344, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.5847083295782514, "rolling10_count": 0, "rolling10_min": null, "rolling10_median": null, "rolling10_ge6_count": 0, "rolling10_ge8_count": 0 }, { "start": "2020-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 6.839291703457292, "final_value": 182476.98116318666, "total_return": 0.8247698116318667, "cagr": 0.09192364821799681, "annualized_volatility": 0.08355251301824643, "max_drawdown": -0.13098456371607226, "max_dd_peak": "2021-12-31", "max_dd_trough": "2022-10-14", "max_dd_recovery": "2023-07-18", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 564, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 563, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-31", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2023-07-17", "id": "variable_BIL_start_2020", "case": { "id": "variable_BIL_start_2020", "rule": "variable_BIL", "start": "2020-01-02" }, "ledger": { "costs": 229.79871076860965, "traded_dollars": 348332.58392412344, "rebalance_events": 83, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 6300.849585960766, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 34646.823912100015, "IEF": -244.39186120694106, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 42003.49823710036, "TLT": 0.0, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 1.076841726899147e-09 }, "annual_returns": { "2020": 0.14094481465044706, "2021": 0.06360221955926115, "2022": -0.08192933287437887, "2023": 0.12981944304699966, "2024": 0.15027156521842722, "2025": 0.22248646382781923, "2026": 0.030942906016932614 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.3008325578963648, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.3314895383740748, "rolling10_count": 0, "rolling10_min": null, "rolling10_median": null, "rolling10_ge6_count": 0, "rolling10_ge8_count": 0 }, { "start": "2020-01-02", "end": "2026-11-04", "years": 6.839291703457292, "final_value": 162627.11702227773, "total_return": 0.6262711702227772, "cagr": 0.07369112134104516, "annualized_volatility": 0.08574921705293634, "max_drawdown": -0.17513709669201782, "max_dd_peak": "2021-12-27", "max_dd_trough": "2022-10-20", "max_dd_recovery": "2024-03-06", "max_dd_peak_to_recovery_days": 800, "longest_underwater_calendar_days": 799, "longest_underwater_start": "2021-12-27", "longest_underwater_last_below": "2024-03-05", "id": "permanent_monthly_start_2020", "case": { "id": "permanent_monthly_start_2020", "rule": "permanent_monthly", "start": "2020-01-02" }, "ledger": { "costs": 232.3626744827709, "traded_dollars": 359291.07120434695, "rebalance_events": 83, "pnl_by_asset": { "BIL": 5818.631472412543, "DBC": 0.0, "GLD": 32285.790729732966, "IEF": 0.0, "IGF": 0.0, "SPY": 33118.0355088831, "TLT": -8362.978014269069, "VNQ": 0.0, "XLE": 0.0, "XLI": 0.0, "XLK": 0.0, "XLU": 0.0 }, "max_self_financing_error": 9.604264050722122e-10 }, "annual_returns": { "2020": 0.1568005229126146, "2021": 0.04595641226250646, "2022": -0.1259646563505913, "2023": 0.11749025617568609, "2024": 0.11678396733364971, "2025": 0.20731089352314314, "2026": 0.02061012053638378 }, "mean_equity_weight": 0.25099914216755614, "maximum_equity_weight": 0.27827466615718316, "rolling10_count": 0, "rolling10_min": null, "rolling10_median": null, "rolling10_ge6_count": 0, "rolling10_ge8_count": 0 } ]